Would You Risk Your Entire Family to Save One Person?

Discussion in 'General Survival and Preparedness' started by Motomom34, Oct 15, 2015.


  1. Motomom34

    Motomom34 Moderator Moderator Site Supporter++

    I found this survival scenario on another blog. I think it is an interesting exercise. Please play along- imagine if your family was gathered or if you don't have family, please think if your close friendsor partner was in another location. Grand kids or distant relatives but it is an interesting question- how much would you risk for one person?

    A natural disaster (like a flood or a fire) is only an hour from hitting your home. You decide to evacuate your family to safer territory, but one of the kids is at a friend’s house located more than an hour away. You know the friend’s family doesn’t practice preparedness and is in harm’s way. Do you evacuate the family you have with you knowing you’ll be completely safe from the disaster? Or do you risk driving through the disaster as it hits to pick up the kid at the friend’s house?
    Survival Scenario: Would You Risk Your Entire Family to Save One Person? | Living Ready Online

    In the link are other people responses but what would you do? Please take into consideration all that could happen if the family unit is divided.Those in the hurricane areas know what traffic is like in a pre-disaster evacuation. Then ask yourself do you have a plan for such a scenario. And if you have a plan, how often do you review the plan with your loved ones. Don't forget in today's world schedules change so what could have been a plan last year, may not apply now.
     
    Tully Mars, Marck, stg58 and 3 others like this.
  2. 3M-TA3

    3M-TA3 Cold Wet Monkey

    Are we talking my dog or my Mother In Law here?
     
  3. Ganado

    Ganado Monkey+++

    I'm like @3M-TA3 depends on who.

    its a great scenario
     
    Tully Mars likes this.
  4. Mindgrinder

    Mindgrinder Karma Pirate Ninja Jedi Bipolar WINNING M.L.F.

    Cold and calculated....it would entirely depend on the "not prepared" teams usefullness in need of rescue DIRECTLY related to the crisis on hand.

    Reality - If I loved them, i'd risk it all without hesitation therefor providing the best possible chance of success in a "time is of the essence" scenario.
    YOLO and it aint worth living without love.

    my .02

    *edit*
    I'd pray and know exactly which choice to make.
    NOT just sayin'.
    Sayin.
     
  5. Motomom34

    Motomom34 Moderator Moderator Site Supporter++

    @3M-TA3 & @Ganado are there two people you love? Imagine one is with you and the other is at the unprepared persons place. Say your wife is with you but your parent is an hour away. What are you going to risk for those you love?
     
    Last edited: Oct 16, 2015
    sec_monkey likes this.
  6. T. Riley

    T. Riley Monkey+++ Site Supporter++

    I could not leave one behind if it were my grandchild or child. I would send the others on their way and get to the missing one if I had to crawl.
     
  7. Dunerunner

    Dunerunner Monkey

    I'm with you on this one @T. Riley. I would gear up and send my family to safety and take alternative transport to get my other child.
     
    Last edited: Oct 16, 2015
  8. Ganado

    Ganado Monkey+++

    If a child or teen I would go after them. if you have two adults you can divide an conquer. The real question is would you drag the other family with you. I probably would. If I trusted them enough for my child to visit them then I better haul them with me.
     
  9. Mountainman

    Mountainman Großes Mitglied Site Supporter+++

    No kids and other family is to far away to even consider going after. Unless the wife is visiting her family she will be no more then 1 hour from home and I would risk everything to get her back home.
     
  10. techsar

    techsar Monkey+++

    I'm looking at this from a different angle. Why is the family member away (with sheeple) when there is a real likelihood of a disaster striking? This situation should never have happened in the first place.
    Having said that, the screw-up would be my fault...so the family would go on without me, while I alone rescued the other member from the sheeple.
    Damn, I hate sheeple.... :cautious:
     
  11. fmhuff

    fmhuff Monkey+++

    Can't answer for anyone but IMHO an man's gotta do what a man's gotta do. And a man has gotta answer that question for himself. We coiuld screw this up to the point that it's an impossible to win scenario, but in my experiece in life so far it's never been so. Of course I don't live in a third world middle easter zealots hell hole either.
     
  12. BTPost

    BTPost Old Fart Snow Monkey Moderator

    In the above senerio, and if I were 15 years younger, I would send AlaskaChick to safety, with the bulk of Family, and I, and Oldest Son, would go get the other Family Member. Since both AlaskaChick, and I, are Hams, we would always have Comms, while we were apart, to coordinate the reunification of the Family. She would use the Family Van, (Mormon Assault Vehicle) and my Son, and I, would be in the 4X4 Truck.
     
    Pax Mentis, fmhuff, Motomom34 and 4 others like this.
  13. TailorMadeHell

    TailorMadeHell Lurking Shadow Creature

    What if it is your family member and they are the sheep?
     
    Tully Mars, Dont and Motomom34 like this.
  14. VHestin

    VHestin Farm Chick

    It's just me and mom here, and since neither of us drive for medical reasons, if we were separated an hour's drive away, depending on the emergency, nothing really could be done. Even if I was able to somehow get to her, no guarantee of getting her home safely. If she was in our 'town' which is only 5miles away, I would try and go get her, taking supplies with me, since I don't know how long it would take me to get her home, she's not very mobile.
     
    Motomom34 likes this.
  15. sec_monkey

    sec_monkey SM Security Administrator

    A variation of the Kobayashi Maru scenario ;) :) [winkthumb]
     
  16. Dunerunner

    Dunerunner Monkey

    As far as saving the other family, I may not have the resources to facilitate that. It could severely reduce the possibility for anyone in the group to survive. That, and the fact that my alternate transportation will only accommodate two people. You have to consider shelter resources, food and water reserves, the ability to defend the group (weapons knowledge) and a whole realm of survival skills and abilities that none of those other folks possess. They would be your personal welfare cases.
     
    Motomom34 likes this.
  17. BTPost

    BTPost Old Fart Snow Monkey Moderator

    They would get a 1 minute "Warning Speech" while I was picking up my Immediate Family Member, and we would depart, Post Haste.... for the reUnification of OUR Immediate FAMILY.... THAT'S IT, Period..... We take care of OUR OWN, FIRST.... Once that is accomplished, then we would see what could be done for Others, in need... and that would include Extended Family, who may not be prepared, like we are...
     
  18. chelloveck

    chelloveck Diabolus Causidicus

    Too many unknown variables to offer a sensible coherent solution. The best one can do is apply some guiding principles.

    1. Which option gives the most probable chance of successfully saving as many people that I care about as possible; including myself?
    2. What risks am I reasonably prepared to take to achieve item 1
    3. Are there more than 2 actual options, and what courses of actions can I take to expand the number of options, and widen the scope of success of the most preferred option.
    4. Do all the people whom I care about justify the same level of risk/sacrifice?
    5. My priority of effort would be:
          • My grandchildren and their parents,
          • My children without dependent children of their own.
          • Siblings and their broods, depending on their utility to my own immediate family's survival..
          • Others, (including more distant relations), depending on their utility to my survival and my family's survival.
          • Parents, and spouses to the extent that they contribute to the survival of my immediate family.
    My reasoning may appear to seem somewhat heartless when it comes to my own parents and spouse, but I would expect no less of my own children in relation to me, nor any less of my parents and spouse were they to make the same decisions about me in respect of their family responsibilities.
     
    Last edited: Oct 16, 2015
  19. 3M-TA3

    3M-TA3 Cold Wet Monkey

    Without humanity I am nothing. Depending on the situation I would get my wife to safety (o safe enough), while I went to get Dad.
    Everyone dies. It's just a matter of when and where. The only thing you have control over is how you live.
     
    Tully Mars, T. Riley, Dont and 3 others like this.
  20. kellory

    kellory An unemployed Jester, is nobody's fool. Banned

    No. Not really. Kobayashi maru, everybody dies, you just chose how. This is more Sophie's choice, choosing who lives and who dies.
     
    NotSoSneaky and Motomom34 like this.
  1. Yard Dart
  2. Yard Dart
  3. Yard Dart
  4. Yard Dart
  5. Tempstar
  6. Yard Dart
  7. Yard Dart
  8. Motomom34
  9. Legion489
  10. Yard Dart
  11. Yard Dart
  12. Legion489
  13. Motomom34
  14. Motomom34
  15. Yard Dart
  16. Yard Dart
  17. Motomom34
  18. Motomom34
  19. Yard Dart
survivalmonkey SSL seal        survivalmonkey.com warrant canary
17282WuJHksJ9798f34razfKbPATqTq9E7